A comparative study on the common temporal norms of chinese аnd russian probate succession system: institutional aspects
Abstract
Testamentary succession is one of the important contents of the inheritance legal system of China and Russia, which fully embodies the spirit of autonomy of private law. Due to the infl uence of different historical culture, traditional customs, economic and political systems and other factors in property inheritance, there exist some legislative differences between China and Russia on the provisions of testator inheritance from the system design concept to the content of the rules. With the detailed and specifi c provisions, the system of testamentary succession in the Russian Federation is deeply infl uenced by the German and Japanese legal systems, while the legislation of testamentary succession in China is relatively principled and brief, which is closely integrated with the reality of China. The analysis of the differences in the basic principles, forms and effectiveness as well as the system of bequest of the two civil codes in both countries in the system of testamentary succession not only contribute to the normative interpretation, application and perfection of the relevant systems of Civil Code in China, but also explores the institutional origin of testamentary succession legislation, so as to realize the balance of testamentary freedom, inheritance justice and social value; At the same time, it also plays a vital role in correctly handling the inheritance relationship between China and Russia, which is also of positive reference signifi cance to the judicial practice of foreign-related inheritance between the two countries.
Keywords
About the Authors
Jian YangChina
Dr. Sсi. (Law), Associate Professor, Russian Law Research Center and Law School
Guan-he Liu
China
Teaching assistant, Graduate School; Research Assistant of Russian Language, China and Culture Research Center
References
1. Amartya Sen. Development as Freedom / translator: Yu Zhen. — Beijing : China Renmin University Press, 2002. — 24.
2. Chen Wei, Song Yu. A Comparative Study of succession law between Mainland China and Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan. — Beijing : Population Press, 2007.
3. Chen Wei. A Comparative Study on Foreign Inheritance Laws and The Formulation of Chinese Civil Code Succession. — Beijing : Peking University Press, 2011.
4. Fang Shao-Kun (editor-in-chief). The Law of kinship and succession (second edition). — Beijing : Science Press, 2015.
5. Hong Guo-Yue. The construction of the principle system of inheritance law // Journal of Guizhou Normal University (Natural Sciences). — 2004 (5).
6. Hu Ping. On marriage and Family Inheritance law. — Chongqing : Chongqing university press, 2000.
7. Magdalena Pfeiffer. Legal certainty and predictability in international succession law // Journal of Private International Law. — 2016. — Is. 3.
8. Maksutova·М.·L. The legal relationship of inheritance in Russia // China Notary. — 2016 (7).
9. Wang Ge-Ya. Codification idea and system conception of the Civil Code Succession // Seeking Truth. — 2018 (6).
10. Wang Ge-Ya. Compilation of Civil Code: Gender consciousness and Normative Expression // Journal of China Women’s University. — 2019 (2).
11. Wang Ge-Ya. On the Revision of Inheritance Law // China Legal Science. — 2013 (6).
12. Wang Ge-Ya. Revision of Succession Law : System construction and system selection // Seeking Truth. — 2013 (2).
13. Wang Ge-Ya. Review and Reference: The Succession system of the Russian Federation // Russian, Central Asian & East European Studies. — 2010 (1).
14. Wang Shu-Qian. Comparative Study on several issues of Inheritance Law between China and Russia [D] // Wuhan University. — 2004 (5) ; 2004 (7).
15. Wang Shu-Qian. Comparison of several issues of Chinese and Russian inheritance laws // Times of law. — 2004 (2).
16. Xu Zeng-Zhen, Zhao Ya-Kun. On the restriction of testamentary Freedom and the Perfection of Inheritance law in China // Forward Position. — 2010 (10).
17. Yang Li-Xin. The Family law. — Beijing : Law Press·China, 2013.
18. Yang Li-Xin. Key points of amendment to the draft succession of civil Code // China Law Abstract. — 2019 (1).
19. Yang Li-Xin. Study on the Succession of The Provisions of Civil Law] // China Legal Science. — 2017 (2).
Review
For citations:
Yang J., Liu G. A comparative study on the common temporal norms of chinese аnd russian probate succession system: institutional aspects. Legal Science in China and Russia. 2021;(4):15-25.